Discover the Best Transportation Management Software to Streamline Your Logistics

Choosing the Best Transportation Management Software (TMS) is a critical decision for any business involved in shipping, logistics, or supply chain management. A robust TMS can optimize your transportation operations, reduce costs, improve efficiency, and enhance customer satisfaction. To help you navigate the complex landscape of TMS solutions, we’ve compiled a guide to some of the leading vendors and essential functionalities to consider when selecting the right platform for your needs.

Selecting the right TMS is not simply about choosing a system; it’s about finding a strategic partner that aligns with your business goals. Many companies fall into the trap of making impulsive decisions based on initial impressions, which can lead to suboptimal outcomes. To avoid this, a structured approach using a detailed requirements document is paramount.

Before diving into specific TMS providers, let’s first understand the importance of a well-defined TMS requirements document. This document serves as your blueprint for selection, ensuring an objective and needs-based decision.

Crafting Your TMS Requirements Document: A Step-by-Step Guide

A comprehensive TMS requirements document is essential for making an informed and objective decision. It prevents decisions based on fleeting excitement and ensures the chosen system truly meets your company’s specific needs. While numerous templates are available, including resources from top TMS providers, customizing and prioritizing your requirements is key.

Here are key functionalities to consider including in your TMS requirements document:

General Functionality

This section outlines the fundamental capabilities of the TMS in supporting your overall transportation needs.

• Inbound, Outbound, and Intercompany: Does the TMS manage all aspects of your freight movements, including inbound shipments from suppliers, outbound deliveries to customers, and intercompany transfers?
• Modes of Freight Supported: Ensure the software supports all the transportation modes you utilize, such as truckload (TL), less-than-truckload (LTL), parcel, rail, air, and ocean.
• Domestic & International Capabilities: If you operate internationally, verify the TMS handles complexities like customs documentation, international regulations, and multi-currency transactions.
• Language & Currency: The TMS should support the languages and currencies relevant to your global operations.
• Geographic Data: Does it provide robust geographic data management for accurate routing, distance calculations, and location-based analytics?
• Technology Architecture (Cloud or Mainframe): Determine your preferred deployment model – cloud-based for accessibility and scalability or mainframe for on-premise control. Cloud solutions are generally favored for their flexibility and lower upfront costs.
• Scalability & Flexibility: The TMS should be able to scale with your business growth and adapt to changing business needs.
• Ease of Integration: Seamless integration with your existing systems, such as ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning), WMS (Warehouse Management System), and order management systems, is crucial for data flow and efficiency. Consider the TMS’s ability to support various data exchange methods like spreadsheets, FTP, EDI, XML, and OCR for document processing.
• Document Management: A centralized document management system within the TMS streamlines access to shipping documents, invoices, and compliance paperwork.
• Capture of Freight Specifications: The system should efficiently capture detailed freight specifications, including dimensions, weight, and special handling requirements. Inquire about the number of customizable fields and flexibility in data capture.
• Support POs for Inbound Management: For inbound logistics, ensure the TMS can manage and integrate with purchase orders (POs).

Rating and Contracts

Efficient rate management and contract negotiation are vital for cost optimization.

• Freight Sourcing and Bid RFP Optimization Tools: Does the TMS offer tools to streamline freight sourcing, manage bid requests (RFPs), and optimize carrier selection based on rates and service levels?
• Modes Supported (Domestic and International): Confirm rate management capabilities cover all your transportation modes, both domestically and internationally.
• Carrier Freight Rating and Contract Management: The TMS should facilitate the management of carrier rates, contracts, and tariffs in a centralized and easily accessible manner.
• Integration to Load Boards: Integration with load boards can expand carrier options and improve spot market procurement.
• Ability to Turn Quotes Immediately to Loads: The system should enable quick conversion of freight quotes into actionable loads for efficient execution.

Strategic and Tactical Planning

Effective planning tools are essential for both long-term strategy and daily operations.

• Analytical Tools for Strategic Planning: Does the TMS provide robust analytical capabilities to support strategic transportation planning, network optimization, and cost analysis?
• Daily Execution Tactical Planning: The software should facilitate tactical planning for daily operations, including load optimization, route planning, and resource allocation.

Operational Planning and Execution

This section focuses on the day-to-day execution of transportation operations.

• Freight Order Management: Streamlined order management functionalities, from order entry to shipment creation, are crucial.
• Consolidation, Pooling, and Stop-Offs: The TMS should optimize loads through consolidation, pooling shipments, and managing multi-stop routes to maximize efficiency and reduce costs.
• Daily Operational Optimization and Planning: Real-time optimization capabilities for daily planning and execution are essential for adapting to dynamic conditions.
• Carrier Assignment and Communication: The system should streamline carrier assignment, dispatch, and communication, including automated notifications and updates.
• Appointment Management: Efficient appointment scheduling and management functionalities help optimize dock scheduling and reduce detention costs.

Optimization Engine

The core of a TMS lies in its optimization engine.

• Data to be Considered in Optimization: Understand what data points the optimization engine considers, such as cost, transit time, service level, and constraints.
• Can Optimization be Immediately Moved to Execution?: The TMS should seamlessly translate optimization plans into executable actions for efficient implementation.

Dedicated Fleet Optimization with Non-Asset Requirements Reporting and Visibility

For businesses with private fleets or those managing a mix of assets and non-assets, these features are critical.

• Track & Trace: Real-time visibility and tracking of shipments are fundamental for proactive management and customer service.
• Exception Alerts & Reporting: Automated alerts for exceptions, delays, and disruptions, coupled with comprehensive reporting, enable timely issue resolution and performance monitoring.

Web Portals

Web portals enhance collaboration and communication with external partners.

• Assign and Brand to Customer: Can you create branded web portals for customers to track shipments and access relevant information?
• Assign by User ID: Secure user ID-based access to web portals ensures data privacy and control.

Settlement

Accurate and efficient freight settlement processes are crucial for financial control.

• Freight Audit, Payment, and Settlement: Automated freight audit, payment processing, and settlement functionalities streamline financial operations and ensure accuracy.
• Support OCR for Carrier Invoices and Document Management: OCR (Optical Character Recognition) capabilities for carrier invoices automate data entry and reduce manual processing.
• Customer Billing: The TMS should facilitate accurate and timely customer billing for freight charges.
• Electronic, Email, EDI, Mail, Etc.: Support for various invoice delivery methods, including electronic, email, EDI, and mail, ensures flexibility and efficiency.

Analytics

Data-driven insights are essential for continuous improvement and strategic decision-making.

• Analytics, Configurable and Flexible Reporting, Ad-Hoc, Static: Robust analytics and reporting capabilities, including configurable, ad-hoc, and static reports, provide valuable insights into transportation performance.
• Dashboards: Interactive dashboards offer a visual overview of key performance indicators (KPIs) and real-time insights.
• Advanced to Support Strategic Analytics: Advanced analytics capabilities should support strategic analysis, trend identification, and predictive modeling.

TMS market analysis for informed decisions

After receiving responses to your requirements document, thoroughly evaluate the findings. Focus on areas of high importance that might not be standard TMS functionalities. Key questions to ask TMS vendors during the discovery process include:

• Custom Code: Can the software provider develop custom code to meet specific requirements?
• Cost of Customization: What are the costs associated with custom development?
• Base Code Integration: Is the vendor willing to incorporate custom code into the base software code? This is crucial for long-term maintainability and upgrades. Custom code outside the base can create significant challenges and costs during future TMS upgrades, potentially leading to an outdated and uncompetitive system.

Upon narrowing down your choices to the top 3 vendors, conduct detailed demos and further refine your decision based on these critical factors:

1. Total Cost of Ownership (TCO): Gain a comprehensive understanding of all costs, including implementation, licensing, maintenance, and potential customization.
2. Ideal Customer Profile: Determine if your company profile aligns with the vendor’s ideal customer base and their focus market.
3. Team and Future Vision: Get to know the vendor’s team, their commitment to customer support, and their roadmap for future platform development.
4. Overall Comfort and Confidence: Ensure you feel confident and comfortable with your chosen vendor as a long-term partner.
5. Implementation Process: Understand the TMS implementation process and timeline to gauge how quickly you can realize the benefits.

Choosing the best transportation management software is a significant investment and a long-term partnership. Think of it as a marriage – the right choice will foster a mutually beneficial and successful relationship for years to come, while a poor decision can lead to costly and painful separation.

To further enhance your TMS selection process, we recommend exploring resources like “Top 10 Transportation Management Software (TMS) Implementation Pitfalls to Avoid” and “Gartner’s Magic Quadrant Analysis Key to TMS Buying Selection Process“. For a deeper dive into the TMS market, capabilities, and solutions, refer to “The Complete Guide to TMS Freight Software: Market, Capabilities and Solutions for Shippers.”

We encourage you to consider these top TMS providers as you embark on your selection journey:

• e2open: Known for its comprehensive TMS covering planning, procurement, execution, and settlement for all modes and regions, suitable for shippers, freight forwarders, carriers, and LSPs.
• Descartes: Offers standalone TMS and managed services with robust domestic and international capabilities for shippers and 3PLs, known for competitive TCO.
• Blue Yonder: A leading SCM suite vendor with a robust TMS platform ideal for large, complex shippers and 3PLs with global supply chain requirements, although TCO can be higher.

Blue Yonder Logo for Transportation Management Software

• Manhattan: TMS deeply integrated with Manhattan’s supply chain applications, often sold as an add-on to their WMS, suitable for companies already invested in the Manhattan ecosystem, but TCO is relatively high.
• MercuryGate: A robust and flexible platform with a strong North American customer base, supporting domestic and international modes for companies of all sizes, offering competitive cost of ownership. Flexibility is a key advantage, allowing for configuration over extensive customization.

.png)

• Oracle: A robust TMS platform for large, complex shippers and 3PLs, increasingly catering to medium-sized businesses, well-suited for global supply chain management, but with a higher TCO.
• SAP: A comprehensive platform integrated with SAP ERP and SCM, suitable for medium to large complex shippers and 3PLs with global operations, partnering with Descartes for carrier communication, but also with a higher TCO.

SAP TMS Logo for Supply Chain Management

• TMC – A Division of C.H. Robinson: Offers a robust TMS developed to support C.H. Robinson’s brokerage operations, strong in managed TM services, suitable for medium to large shippers, but standalone TMS pricing can be complex.
• Trimble: TMS with capabilities for both asset and non-asset based operations, often favored by carriers and brokers, primarily focused on North American domestic freight.

Trimble Logo for Transportation Technology

• Uber Freight TMS (formerly Transplace): Increasingly focused on its standalone TMS offering, strong in managed TM, North American focused with domestic and international capabilities (through partnerships), competitive TCO, and geared towards medium to large shippers.

We hope this guide provides valuable insights for your best transportation management software selection process. We at InTek Freight & Logistics are ready to assist you in your TMS journey. Contact us today to discuss your needs and explore how we can help optimize your transportation operations.

[