Transportation Ciphers, also known as transposition ciphers, represent a fascinating cornerstone in the world of cryptography. These ingenious methods focus on rearranging the order of characters within a message, rather than substituting them, to achieve encryption. By scrambling the sequence of letters according to a specific key, transportation ciphers transform readable plaintext into seemingly nonsensical ciphertext, safeguarding sensitive information from prying eyes. This article delves into the intricacies of transportation ciphers, exploring their mechanisms, decryption techniques, and significance in the broader landscape of secure communication.
What is a Transportation Cipher? (Definition)
At its core, a transportation cipher is a method of encryption that operates by permuting the positions of characters in the plaintext message. Unlike substitution ciphers, which replace characters with others, transportation ciphers maintain the original characters but alter their order, creating a scrambled message that is unintelligible without the decryption key. This rearrangement is governed by a “transportation key,” also referred to as a “permutation key,” which dictates the specific order in which the characters are to be reorganized.
The term “transportation cipher” serves as a broad classification encompassing any encryption technique that involves rearranging letter order. However, within cryptographic literature, it often specifically refers to columnar transposition, a widely recognized and utilized subset. Columnar transposition involves writing the plaintext message into a grid or table of predetermined width and then rearranging the columns of this grid based on the transportation key. This method forms the basis for many transportation cipher variations and is a key concept in understanding this type of encryption.
What is a Transportation Key?
The effectiveness of a transportation cipher hinges on the transportation key, also known as the permutation key. This key is essentially a sequence of numbers that defines the order in which the columns of the transposition grid should be arranged. Often, this numerical sequence is derived from a keyword or phrase, adding an element of memorability and complexity to the cipher.
Consider the keyword “KEY” as an example. To derive a permutation key from this word, we first assign numerical positions to each letter based on their alphabetical order.
| Before alphabetical sort | After alphabetical sort |
|---|---|
| Word | K,E,Y |
| Column Order | 1,2,3 |
In “KEY,” ‘E’ is the first letter alphabetically, ‘K’ is second, and ‘Y’ is third. Thus, the permutation key derived from “KEY” becomes 2,1,3, indicating that in the transposition process, the second column should come first, the first column second, and the third column third. This numerical sequence is crucial for both encryption and decryption, ensuring that only those with the correct key can decipher the message.
How to Encrypt Using a Transportation Cipher?
The columnar transportation cipher method involves a structured approach to encryption using a grid and a permutation key. The process typically involves writing the plaintext message into a table of a specific width, determined by the size of the permutation key. The message is written row by row (or column by column), and then the columns are permuted according to the order specified in the key. Finally, the ciphertext is read from the table, usually in columns (or rows, depending on the variant).
Let’s illustrate with an example. Suppose we want to encrypt the message “MESSAGE” using columnar transposition with the key “CODE,” which yields the permutation 1,3,4,2.
| Columns | 1,2,3,4 | Sorted cols | 1,3,4,2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plain text | M,E,S,S | Cipher text | M,S,S,E |
| A,G,E,_ | A,E,_,G |
- Grid Creation: We set up a grid with 4 columns, corresponding to the length of the key “CODE.”
- Plaintext Input: We write the plaintext “MESSAGE” row by row into the grid.
- Column Permutation: We rearrange the columns according to the permutation key 1,3,4,2. This means the first column stays in place, the third column moves to the second position, the fourth to the third, and the second to the fourth.
- Ciphertext Output: Reading the table column by column, we obtain the ciphertext “MASESEG”.
Variations of columnar transposition exist, such as reading the table row by row instead of column by column after permutation. In our example, reading by rows would result in “MASES_EG” (assuming ‘_’ represents a space or padding character).
In practical applications, especially for manual decryption, grids might contain empty cells at the end if the plaintext length is not a multiple of the column number. To simplify decryption, these empty boxes are often filled with a neutral letter, such as ‘X’ or another frequent letter, to maintain a rectangular structure.
How to Decrypt with a Transportation Cipher?
Decrypting a transportation cipher is essentially the reverse process of encryption. It utilizes the same transportation key but applies the inverse permutation to restore the original order of the characters.
If the ciphertext’s length is not a multiple of the permutation key size, it’s necessary to determine the positions of any padding characters or empty cells in the grid. This can be done by simulating the encryption process to understand how the grid was originally filled.
Let’s consider an example where a permutation 2,1,3 was used to encrypt a message, and the resulting ciphertext (read by row) is “CDOEDX.” To decrypt this:
| Columns | 2,1,3 | Sorted columns | 1,2,3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ciphertext | C,D,O | Plaintext | D,C,O |
| E,D,X | D,E,X |
- Grid Setup: Create a grid with 3 columns (key size).
- Ciphertext Input: Fill the grid row by row with the ciphertext “CDOEDX.”
- Inverse Permutation: Apply the inverse of the permutation 2,1,3, which is 2,1,3 itself in this specific case (because swapping 1 and 2 twice returns to the original order, though in general inverse permutation needs to be calculated). Rearrange columns based on the sorted column order (1,2,3).
- Plaintext Output: Read the table row by row to get the plaintext “DCODEX.”
If the ciphertext was read by columns during encryption, the decryption process would begin by writing the ciphertext into the grid column by column and then applying the inverse permutation before reading out the plaintext.
For example, if the ciphertext “CEDDOX” was obtained using permutation 2,1,3 and read by column:
| Columns | 2,1,3 | Sorted columns | 1,2,3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ciphertext | C,D,O | Plaintext | D,C,O |
| E,D,X | D,E,X |
The decryption steps remain similar, but the initial writing of ciphertext into the grid is done column-wise to reverse the column-wise reading during encryption.
How to Recognize a Transportation Ciphertext?
Identifying a ciphertext as potentially originating from a transportation cipher involves recognizing certain characteristics. The most prominent indicator is that the ciphertext consists of the same letters as expected in the plaintext language, but they appear in a disordered arrangement. This suggests a rearrangement of characters rather than a substitution.
A valuable tool for confirming this is the index of coincidence. For a transportation cipher, the index of coincidence of the ciphertext will be very similar to that of the language of the original plaintext. This is because the frequency of individual letters is preserved in transportation ciphers, unlike substitution ciphers which alter letter frequencies.
However, the bigram index of coincidence, which measures the frequency of letter pairs, will typically be significantly different in a transportation ciphertext compared to the plaintext language. This is because the transposition process disrupts the natural pairings and sequences of letters common in the original language.
How to Decipher a Transportation Cipher Without a Key?
Deciphering a transportation cipher without knowing the key can be challenging but is achievable through various cryptanalysis techniques. For short keys, one approach is to systematically test all possible permutations. The number of permutations grows factorially with the key length, so this method is feasible for smaller keys but becomes computationally intensive for longer ones.
A more effective method, especially when some plaintext context is anticipated, is to try to guess a word or phrase that might be present in the original message. By attempting to align this guessed word within the ciphertext and analyzing the resulting column permutations, it may be possible to deduce the key or parts of it.
If the ciphertext is very short, consisting of just a few words, anagram solvers can be surprisingly effective. Since transportation ciphers retain the original letters, rearranging the letters of a short ciphertext using an anagram solver might reveal potential plaintext words or phrases.
What are the Variants of the Transportation Cipher?
Transportation ciphers, due to their simplicity and effectiveness as a component of more complex systems, are fundamental building blocks in cryptography. Numerous advanced ciphers incorporate transportation techniques as part of their encryption process. Some notable variants and ciphers that utilize transportation include:
- ADFGVX Cipher: A classical cipher that combines substitution and transportation, offering enhanced security.
- Amsco Cipher: A type of columnar transposition cipher that uses a more complex, keyword-based method for determining column order.
- Double Transposition Cipher: Applies columnar transposition twice, significantly increasing the complexity and security of the encryption.
- Redefence Cipher: A rail fence cipher variant that can be considered a form of transportation, involving writing plaintext diagonally and then reading it row by row.
These variants demonstrate the versatility of transportation principles in creating more robust and sophisticated encryption methods.
Why Completing the Empty Cells of the Transportation Table?
In columnar transposition, if the plaintext length is not an exact multiple of the column width, the last row of the grid will have empty cells. While these empty cells do not inherently compromise the encryption, they can introduce complications during manual decryption.
If empty cells are left unfilled, the recipient of the message must calculate their positions to correctly reconstruct the grid and perform decryption. This requires extra steps and can be time-consuming and error-prone, especially when dealing with longer messages or complex keys.
Filling the empty cells with a neutral character, such as ‘X’ or a common letter, ensures that the grid is always rectangular and fully populated. This eliminates the need for the recipient to calculate empty cell positions, simplifying the decryption process and reducing the likelihood of errors in letter reorganization, particularly for the final characters of the message.
Source code
dCode retains ownership of the “Transportation Cipher” source code. Except explicit open source licence (indicated Creative Commons / free), the “Transportation Cipher” algorithm, the applet or snippet (converter, solver, encryption / decryption, encoding / decoding, ciphering / deciphering, breaker, translator), or the “Transportation Cipher” functions (calculate, convert, solve, decrypt / encrypt, decipher / cipher, decode / encode, translate) written in any informatic language (Python, Java, PHP, C#, Javascript, Matlab, etc.) and all data download, script, or API access for “Transportation Cipher” are not public, same for offline use on PC, mobile, tablet, iPhone or Android app! Reminder : dCode is free to use.
Cite dCode
The copy-paste of the page “Transportation Cipher” or any of its results, is allowed (even for commercial purposes) as long as you credit dCode! Exporting results as a .csv or .txt file is free by clicking on the export icon Cite as source (bibliography): Transportation Cipher on dCode.fr [online website], retrieved on 2025-03-02, https://www.dcode.fr/transposition-cipher
